Journal of the Chinese Medical Association
Volume 73, Issue 5 , Pages 241-247, May 2010

Superiority of Nitinol Piston Over Conventional Prostheses in Stapes Surgery: First Comparative Results in the Chinese Population in Taiwan

  • Chin-Lung Kuo
    • ,
  • Mao-Che Wang
    • ,
  • An-Suey Shiao

      Affiliations

    • Corresponding Author InformationCorrespondence to: Dr An-Suey Shiao, Department of Otolaryngology, Taipei Veterans General Hospital, 201, Section 2, Shih-Pai Road, Taipei 112, Taiwan, R.O.C.

Department of Otolaryngology, Taipei Veterans General Hospital, and National Yang-Ming University School of Medicine, Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C.

Received 14 December 2009; accepted 13 April 2010.

Article Outline

Background

A growing number of studies conducted on stapes surgery have suggested that firm and adequate attachment of the prosthesis onto the long process of the incus plays a key role in surgical success. For this reason, a new prosthesis made of Nitinol characterized by “self-crimping” has been developed. Although better postoperative outcomes achieved with a Nitinol piston have been previously confirmed, the superiority of the Nitinol piston over the conventional manual-crimping prostheses remains controversial. The aim of this study was to determine the advantages of the Nitinol piston with regard to hearing improvement.

Methods

We retrospectively compared postoperative hearing in otosclerosis surgeries with the Nitinol piston versus the manual-crimping prostheses. Sixteen surgeries with Nitinol pistons (carried out between April 2007 and August 2009) and 21 surgeries with conventional prostheses (carried out between January 2004 and January 2009) were evaluated. All patients received pure-tone audiograms preoperatively and postoperatively.

Results

In the Nitinol piston group, the air-bone gap (ABG) average (7.92 ± 6.75 dBHL) was significantly smaller postoperatively than preoperatively (26.79 ± 8.33 dBHL, p < 0.001). Similarly, the ABG average for the conventional piston group (13.09 ± 6.99 dBHL) was significantly smaller postoperatively than preoperatively (26.19 ± 6.76 dBHL, p < 0.001). Although both groups demonstrated an improvement in average ABG postoperatively, the Nitinol piston group showed a greater improvement than the conventional piston group (p = 0.018). Additionally, ABG closure within 10 dB was attained in significantly more patients (75%) in the Nitinol piston group compared with the conventional piston group (33.3%, p = 0.012).

Conclusion

The Nitinol piston has a distinct advantage over conventional prostheses, providing an easier, safer and more effective treatment option in otosclerosis surgery. To our knowledge, this is the first comparative analysis of hearing results of the Nitinol piston with conventional prostheses in the Chinese population in Taiwan. In this population, there is a much lower prevalence of otosclerosis, leading to a lack of surgical experience in otosclerosis surgery, even at large medical centers. This may explain, in part, the relative lack of studies conducted on stapes prostheses in Asian patients. Therefore, our preliminary research may provide a reference for future investigations on stapes surgery in Asian patients with otosclerosis based on ethnic differences.

Key Words:  nitinol piston , otosclerosis , stapes prosthesis , stapes surgery

No full text is available. To read the body of this article, please view the PDF online.

 

Back to Article Outline

References 

  1. Shea JJ . Symposium; the operation for the mobilization of the stapes in otosclerotic deafness . Laryngoscope . 1956;66:729–784
  2. McGee TM . The loose wire syndrome . Laryngoscope . 1981;91:1478–1483
  3. Kwok P , Fisch U , Strutz J , May J . Stapes surgery: how precisely do different prostheses attach to the long process of the incus with different instruments and different surgeons? . Otol Neurotol . 2002;23:289–295
  4. Huber AM , Ma F , Felix H , Linder T . Stapes prosthesis attachment: the effect of crimping on sound transfer in otosclerosis surgery . Laryngoscope . 2003;113:853–858
  5. Huttenbrink KB . Biomechanics of stapesplasty: a review . Otol Neurotol . 2003;24:548–557
  6. Knox GW , Reitan H . Shape-memory stapes prosthesis for otosclerosis surgery . Laryngoscope . 2005;115:1340–1346
  7. Fritsch MH , Naumann IC . Phylogeny of the stapes prosthesis . Otol Neurotol . 2008;29:407–415
  8. Mihálcz I . Fundamental characteristics and design method for nickel-titanium shape memory alloy . Periodica Polytechnica Ser Mech Eng . 2001;45:75–86
  9. Machado LG , Savi MA . Medical applications of shape memory alloys . Braz J Med Biol Res . 2003;36:683–691
  10. Morgan NB . Medical shape memory alloy applications: the market and its products . Mat Sci Eng . 2004;378:16–23
  11. Cha SY , Jeong SY , Park JH , Park SE , Park JK , Cho CR . Thermodynamic and structural characterization of high-and low-temperature Nitinol . J Korean Phys Soc . 2006;49:S580–S583
  12. Pun DK , Berzins DW . Corrosion behavior of shape memory, superelastic, and nonsuperelastic nickel-titanium-based orthodontic wires at various temperatures . Dent Mater . 2008;24:221–227
  13. Babighian G , Fontana M , Caltran S , Ciccolella M , Amadori M , De Zen M . The heat-activated stapes prosthesis ‘SMart’ Piston: technique and preliminary results . Adv Otorhinolaryngol . 2007;65:190–196
  14. Brown KD , Gantz BJ . Hearing results after stapedotomy with a nitinol piston prosthesis . Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg . 2007;133:758–762
  15. Gerlinger I , Toth M , Bako P , Nemeth A , Pytel J . KTP-laser stapedotomy with a self-crimping, thermal shape memory Nitinol SMart piston: 1 year follow-up results: how we do it . Clin Otolaryngol . 2008;33:475–480
  16. Hornung JA , Brase C , Bozzato A , Zenk J , Schick B , Iro H . Retrospective analysis of the results of implanting Nitinol pistons with heat-crimping piston loops in stapes surgery . Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol . 2010;267:27–34
  17. Hornung J , Zenk J , Schick B , Wurm J , Iro H . First experiences with a new nickel-titanium piston with a shape memory feature . HNO . 2007;55:104–108 [In German]
  18. Rajan GP , Eikelboom RH , Anandacoomaraswamy KS , Atlas MD . In vivo performance of the Nitinol shape-memory stapes prosthesis during hearing restoration surgery in otosclerosis: a first report . J Biomed Mater Res B Appl Biomater . 2005;72:305–309
  19. Harris JP , Gong S . Comparison of hearing results of nitinol SMART stapes piston prosthesis with conventional piston prostheses: postoperative results of nitinol stapes prosthesis . Otol Neurotol . 2007;28:692–695
  20. Huber AM , Veraguth D , Schmid S , Roth T , Eiber A . Tight stapes prosthesis fixation leads to better functional results in otosclerosis surgery . Otol Neurotol . 2008;29:893–899
  21. Pudel EI , Briggs RJS . Laser-assisted stapedotomy with a Nitinol heat-crimping prosthesis: outcomes compared with a platinum fluoroplastic prosthesis . Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg . 2008;139:51–54
  22. Tenney J , Arriaga MA , Chen DA , Arriaga R . Enhanced hearing in heat-activated-crimping prosthesis stapedectomy . Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg . 2008;138:513–517
  23. Markou K , Goudakos J . An overview of the etiology of otosclerosis . Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol . 2009;266:25–35
  24. Lee TL , Wang MC , Lirng JF , Liao WH , Yu EC , Shiao AS . High-resolution computed tomography in the diagnosis of otosclerosis in Taiwan . J Chin Med Assoc . 2009;72:527–532
  25. Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium guidelines for the evaluation of results of treatment of conductive hearing loss. American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery Foundation, Inc . Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg . 1995;113:186–187
  26. New and revised reporting guidelines from the Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium. American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery Foundation, Inc . Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg . 1995;113:176–178
  27. Rajan GP , Atlas MD , Subramaniam K , Eikelboom RH . Eliminating the limitations of manual crimping in stapes surgery? A preliminary trial with the shape memory Nitinol stapes piston . Laryngoscope . 2005;115:366–369
  28. Rajan GP, Diaz J, Blackham R, Eikelboom RH, Atlas MD, Shelton C, et al. Eliminating the limitations of manual crimping in stapes surgery: mid-term results of 90 patients in the Nitinol stapes piston multicenter trial . Laryngoscope . 2007;117:1236–1239
  29. Skinner M , Honrado C , Prasad M , Kent HN , Selesnick SH . The incudostapedial joint angle: implications for stapes surgery prosthesis selection and crimping . Laryngoscope . 2003;113:647–653
  30. Pudel EI , Briggs RJ . Laser-assisted stapedotomy with a Nitinol heat-crimping prosthesis: outcomes compared with a platinum fluoroplastic prosthesis . Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg . 2008;139:51–54
  31. Shahnaz N , Bork K . Wideband reflectance norms for Caucasian and Chinese young adults . Ear Hear . 2006;27:774–788
  32. Shahnaz N , Davies D . Standard and multifrequency tympano-metric norms for Caucasian and Chinese young adults . Ear Hear . 2006;27:75–90
  33. Takeshita F , Takata H , Ayukawa Y , Suetsugu T . Histomorpho-metric analysis of the response of rat tibiae to shape memory alloy (nitinol) . Biomaterials . 1997;18:21–25
  34. Bryld LE , Hindsberger C , Kyvik KO , Agner T , Menne T . Genetic factors in nickel allergy evaluated in a population-based female twin sample . J Invest Dermatol . 2004;123:1025–1029
  35. Lamberti M, Perfetto B, Costabile T, Canozo N, Baroni A, Liotti F, et al  In vitro evaluation of matrix metallo-proteinases as predictive testing for nickel, a model sensitizing agent . Toxicol Appl Pharmacol . 2004;195:321–330
  36. Es-Souni M , Fischer-Brandies H . Assessing the biocompatibility of NiTi shape memory alloys used for medical applications . Anal Bioanal Chem . 2005;381:557–567

PII: S1726-4901(10)70052-6

doi:10.1016/S1726-4901(10)70052-6

Journal of the Chinese Medical Association
Volume 73, Issue 5 , Pages 241-247, May 2010

Article Tools